Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: World Building: Fantasy vs. Science Fiction
Browsing all 11 articles
Browse latest View live

By: jp

My only comment is that I don’t think Clarke’s Law was intended to be applied to storytelling. It’s meant to be used in the ‘real world’ where sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from...

View Article



By: John

Update: John Scalzi offers his own acid test of sf vs. fantasy.

View Article

By: Blog, Jvstin Style

Even more SF versus Fantasy discussion SFSignal: World Building: Fantasy vs. Science Fiction That cross-blog/Lj discussion about the differences between SF and Fantasy that involves Chiang, Monette,...

View Article

By: Allan Rosewarne

Boys and girls, goin to add my $0.02. But I see John Scalzi’s explanation incomplete and non-sastifying, IMO, he’s relying on the tropes used by the story {“Batteries” vs. mystical god power source)...

View Article

By: Scott

FYI – legal scholars chill, Ed Meese did not say the line attributed to him by JP, but instead Justice Potter Stewart in a concurring opinion in 1964 overturning a ban on pornographic film.

View Article


By: Scott

My commentary on SF vs F. They are cut from the same cloth. They are too alike to be claimed as different. That you like one or the other is nice – read what you like and feel free to judge a book by...

View Article

By: John

The saga continues… Ted Chiang restates his argument.

View Article

By: John

Oh, and Hal Duncan has something to say, too.

View Article


By: jp

And I have something to say too: You never see Ed Meese and Potter Stewart together do you? I rest my case.

View Article


By: John C. Wright

The official John C. Wright definitions are: Science Fiction is the mythology of the scientific age; fantasy is the nostalgia of the scientific age for the pre-scientific world view was have (some of...

View Article

By: Scott

To me it all comes back to how you’re most able to suspend your disbelief. That’s what fiction is all about really – getting you to enjoy the story – no matter the genre or subject – through...

View Article
Browsing all 11 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images